Written By Pavan Punja

Here’s what drives me crazy: most local businesses already have a Google Business Profile, but they’re getting exactly zero calls, zero walk-ins, and zero leads from it.

And they blame Google.

But it’s not Google’s fault. It’s how the profile is set up—or more accurately, how it’s been abandoned after five minutes of half-hearted effort.

Google ranks businesses based on three things: relevance, how complete your profile is, and whether you actually use it. Make common Google Business Profile mistakes, and Google will quietly stop showing you to customers. Even if you’re real, verified, and literally around the corner from someone searching.

The good news? Fixing these mistakes doesn’t require paying for ads or hiring an SEO expert. It just requires doing things correctly and staying somewhat active.

Let’s talk about the five mistakes that are silently killing your visibility.

Google Business Profile Mistake 1: Wrong Primary Category

Your primary category is hands-down the most important ranking factor in Google Business Profile.

It’s basically Google’s cheat sheet for understanding: “What searches should I show this business for?”

Here’s an example. Say you run a gym. Google lets you pick from several categories:

• Gym
• Fitness Center
• Health Club
• Personal Trainer

All of them are technically correct. But only one can be your primary category, and that choice matters more than you think.

If most people in your area search “gym near me” but you’ve selected “Fitness Center” as your primary category, Google will show your competitors instead of you. That’s it. Game over.

Google matches search terms to categories to profiles. If your category doesn’t match what people actually type, you disappear from their results.

You can add secondary categories (and you should), but the primary one controls your ranking.

How to pick the right one:

Open Google and search “[your service] + near me”—like “gym near me” or “salon near me.”

Look at what the top three businesses use as their main category. That’s your answer. Pick the one that matches what your customers actually search for, not what sounds fanciest.

Wrong category = wrong traffic = zero leads. It’s that simple.

Mistake 2: Incomplete Profile

Google rewards complete profiles, and it punishes lazy ones.

Most invisible businesses are missing basic information like:

• Business description
• List of services
• Working hours
• Service areas
• Photos
• Website link

Google uses all of this to understand what you do and who should see you. An incomplete profile tells Google: “This business isn’t serious.”

Meanwhile, fully completed profiles get more impressions, more clicks, and more calls. The math is pretty straightforward.

Here’s the frustrating part: completing your Google Business Profile takes about 30 minutes and costs absolutely nothing. Yet most businesses leave it half-empty and then wonder why they’re not getting customers.

If you’ve got 30 minutes and you want more leads, go fill out your profile. All of it.

Mistake 3: No Photos (Or Photos From 2019)

Google’s own data shows that businesses with photos get 42% more requests for directions and 35% more website clicks.

Photos answer three critical questions for potential customers:

1. Are you real?
2. Do you look professional?
3. Can I trust you?

Your profile should have photos of:

• Your storefront or office
• Interior shots
• Your team
• Work samples or products
• Your logo
• A decent cover photo

And here’s the thing: photos from 2019 hurt you in 2026. They scream “abandoned business” even if you’re open every day.

Google also favors profiles that upload new photos regularly because it signals activity. It shows you’re engaged and still running.

Update your photos at least once every three months. New project? Take a photo. New team member? Add their picture. It takes two minutes and it works.

Mistake 4: Ignoring Reviews

Reviews do two critical things for your business:

1. They build customer trust
2. They improve your local ranking

Google treats reviews as a ranking signal. If you’re not responding to reviews, ignoring the bad ones, or never asking customers to leave feedback, your profile slowly sinks in the rankings.

People also judge you by how you respond to reviews—especially negative ones. A professional response shows you care about customers and you’re willing to fix problems.

Simple template for negative reviews:

“Thanks for the feedback. We’re sorry your experience didn’t meet expectations. Please reach out to us directly at [phone/email] so we can make this right.”

That’s it. You’ve acknowledged the issue, shown professionalism, and protected your reputation. Plus, you’ve signaled to Google that you’re active and engaged.

No responses? Google assumes you don’t care about customers. And if you don’t care, why should Google show you to more people?

Mistake 5: Zero Activity (The Silent Killer)

Google wants to show businesses that are alive and actively serving customers.

Profiles that post updates, add photos, collect reviews, and respond to customers rank higher. It’s not a mystery—it’s Google’s way of filtering out dead or abandoned businesses.

If your profile hasn’t had a post, an update, or any new activity in months, Google slowly pushes you down in the rankings. You might be open for business, but your profile looks abandoned.

You should post at least once a week. It doesn’t have to be complicated:

• Announce a sale or special offer
• Share a new service
• Post a helpful tip
• Highlight a customer success story
• Promote an upcoming event

Each post tells Google: “This business is active and relevant.”

Inactive profiles get buried. Even if everything else is perfect.

How to Actually Fix These Mistakes

Don’t try to fix everything at once—you’ll get overwhelmed and quit. Here’s a smarter approach:

1: Search your business name on Google and open your Business Profile.

2: Run through this checklist and see what’s missing:

• Primary category correct?
• Services listed?
• Description written?
• Hours accurate?
• Photos recent?
• Reviews being responded to?
• Any posts in the last month?

3: Fix one thing per week:

• Week 1: Fix your categories
• 2nd week: Complete your profile (description, services, hours)
• 3rd week: Upload fresh photos
• 4th week: Respond to all reviews
• 5th week: Start posting weekly updates

4: Check your Insights tab monthly.

Track calls, profile views, direction requests, and website clicks. When those numbers go up, you know your fixes are working.

​

Final Thoughts

Most businesses aren’t failing because they lack a Google Business Profile. They’re failing because they’re making one (or all five) of these mistakes.

The frustrating part? These are all fixable in a few hours. No budget required. No technical skills needed. Just attention to detail and a little bit of consistency.

If your profile is currently invisible, you’re not competing with huge budgets or fancy marketing teams. You’re competing with basic competence. And that’s a game you can win.

Need help fixing your Google Business Profile the right way?
Schoracle offers professional GMB setup, optimization, and ongoing management so your profile actually works for you.
Visit our GMB services page to get started.